Acne Treatment with Lasers & Photodynamic Therapy (PDT)
For over 20 years we have specialized in Integrative & Laser Medicine. Our expertise includes a broad spectrum of treatments for cystic acne and skin. From conducting our own independent research to utilizing well established conventional acne therapies. We have explored the use of virtually every applicable technology, from the most expensive and sophisticated medical lasers, to the simplest and most “natural” remedies for acne, with which we have administered over 85 thousand treatments.
We are particular focused on using “evidenced based science” to develop acne protocols that achieve the best possible clinical results. What we have found is that the best possible results to get rid of acne are often achieved by combining different treatment modalities. This “Multiple Modality” approach has been particularly rewarded by the recent advancement in laser sciences and the many different types of medical lasers now available that we can use in combination protocols for acne.
Far and away the most effective acne treatment that we have found for common and light to moderate cystic acne are treatments that utilize lasers and Photodynamic Therapy. In fact, we have tracked cystic acne patients who underwent our protocols for over nine years without recurrence.
Laser Treatment for Acne Explained
In addition to the remarkable efficacy of laser protocols, lasers offer the added benefit of being completely natural therapies with absolutely no side effects.
Lasers emit pure energy in the form of a single specific frequency of light. Their effect extends only to the local tissue in the targeted area. Thus, unlike drugs, lasers have no systemic negative side-effects that involve other organs systems. Additionally, as lasers are able to work on, in, and under the skin without cutting the skin and exposing a vulnerable wound, laser treatments are non-invasive.
Are Lasers Safe?
Many acne patients ask about the energy that lasers emit, and whether or not there are hidden dangers in being exposed to it. Lasers have been used in medicine for over 50 years. They are powerful, and unskilled use can definitely damage you. Thus, expertise in their use should always be employed.
However, other than the direct, instantaneous and local effects of the energy on the targeted tissue, no side effects on human physiology have ever been reported. A laser will affect only the targeted tissue exactly at the moment of treatment, nothing more, nothing less.
Also the frequencies of energy used are nowhere near the very short waves of “radiation” energy that are used in X-rays and nuclear medicine. Therefore, as long as the laser is being skillfully used, they are completely safe, and do not cause side effects.
Lasers are Target Specific
As mentioned earlier, lasers emit a single frequency of energy. Because of that, lasers are very “target specific”. A particular frequency of energy might be easily absorbed by blood, but not be absorbed at all by collagen, fingernails or warts. Therefore, to target different components in your skin, it is best to have a collection of different lasers that each target specific and distinct tissue.
Once the best match has been found between a particular tissue or cell type and the specific frequency of energy that targets it best, the energy can then be manipulated or “modulated” in many ways to achieve the desired response from the tissue.
The Different Types of Lasers used During Acne Treatment
Though years of research were required to discover the most effective protocol for acne, the treatments are actually quite simple. Depending on the severity of the acne, and the responsiveness of the patient’s physiology, a series of 3-5 acne treatments are typically needed, wherein three different types of lasers are used during each treatment.
(For a better understanding of the physiology involved in these laser acne treatments, please refer to subsequent articles on the Basic Science of Acne.)
Laser #1 : Nd:YAG
With a frequency of 1064nm, the Nd:YAG laser targets sebaceous glands in order to reduce or shut down the over production of sebum (oil).
The Nd:YAG is an infrared laser and the energy of that laser will get collected and concentrated inside the sebaceous gland and dry it up and shrink it down.
It’s not the only laser that does that, nor is it the only frequency that works, but it is the best of all of the different lasers to choose from.
Laser #2 : Vascular Laser
The vascular laser targets inflammation. The body’s physiological response to acne includes an inflammatory immune reaction. That is what makes pimples red and swollen.
The inflammation is also the cause of much of the acne scarring that is associated with severe cystic acne. Shutting down the immune response will greatly accelerate the healing of the acne.
Note: In the case where the inflammation is also in response to a bacterial infection of the skin, it is important to provide something to directly combat the bacteria such as oral antibiotics or antibacterial cream.
Laser #3 : Ablative Laser
Targets the Stratum Corneum of the epithelium. Precisely removing this uppermost dead layer of skin opens up the pores and allows your skin to “breath” and expel trapped sebum (oil). This is particularly important after Laser #1, because treated sebaceous glands will often purge their excess contents.
Furthermore, when this procedure is done correctly, it will also stimulate the renewal of your entire epithelium. In approximately 3-5 days, a brand new army of epithelial cells will march to the surface and push off the old epithelium. You will undergo a dry flakey peel during these days, revealing a bright new and radiant epithelium underneath.
Treatments with Laser #3, which we designate as an “epithelial peel and regeneration” are very popular among women who otherwise spend considerable time and money regularly exfoliating. Even without acne, many women book this treatment on a monthly basis.
Recovery from Laser Acne Treatment
During the week following this procedure, the skin is particularly vulnerable to negative influences. It is important to protect the skin from direct sunlight.
Additionally, to protect and nourish the skin after this procedure, special creams should be used. We are particularly dedicated to the use of natural substances that do not introduce any artificial substances to the skin during this vulnerable week. Using a moisture barrier is particularly important during the week following the procedure, to protect the skin from drying out.
Photodynamic Therapy (PDT) for Acne Explained
When patients with severe cystic acne come to us as candidates for Photodynamic Therapy, it’s because they are at the end of their rope. Typically, they have tried everything else already, sometimes more than once, and nothing has worked.
Some have even tried , and some, unbelievably, even took on the risk more than once. Others are desperately trying to avoid Accutane and are searching for one more option before they truly have no other last resort.
For these patients, we have found that PDT, when combined with other specific therapies in a customized protocol will truly heal their terrible cystic acne 95% of the time.
The Science of Photodynamic Therapy
Photodynamic therapy is based on a natural biochemical reaction that is already taking place within sebaceous glands. PDT amplifies this biochemical reaction to the point where it shuts down the hyperactivity and overgrowth (hypertrophy) of problem sebaceous glands.
Meet the Porphyrin
At the heart of this biochemistry is a Porphyrin molecule. Porphyrins are a class of molecules that are prevalent in human physiology, most notably as part of the hemoglobin complex of molecules. Porphyrins also happen to be produced most everywhere fast replicating cells happen to be… such as in overactive sebaceous glands.
Another remarkable characteristic of many Porphyrins is their innate capacity to absorb specific frequencies of light. (In plant life, porphyrins are present as part of the chlorophyll complex of molecules that are essential in absorbing solar energy (sunlight) and converting it into chemical energy.) When porphyrins present in sebaceous glands are thus activated by specific frequencies of light, they release a “singlet oxygen” atom, which is very toxic to other living cells, and quickly kills them.
The Singlet Oxygen Atom
A “singlet oxygen” is a lone oxygen atom with a single free electron. It is not bound to any other atom, not even another oxygen, as in the oxygen molecules we breathe; O2. When singlet oxygen atoms are released within a hyperactive and overgrown sebaceous gland, they quickly kill the overactive sebaceous cells, reducing the gland’s hyperactivity and over-growth, forcing the gland back into proper physiological function.
However, there is not a high enough concentration of naturally occurring porphyrins in hyperactive sebaceous glands to produce a reaction intense enough to shut down the gland. Thus a patient must first be treated with Aminolevulinic Acid (ALA) which increases the amount of porphyrins being produced in the sebaceous gland.
A One Shot Bullet
For those who are wondering about singlet oxygen atoms damaging other surrounding tissue, that’s a good question. Fortunately, once a singlet oxygen atom has attacked a nearby cell, it itself is deactivated by that interaction, and thus can only attack once. It is essentially a “one shot bullet”.
Furthermore, the reaction takes only a second to run it course. Therefore, only cells in the immediate area where singlet oxygen atoms are released, inside our problem sebaceous glands, will be subject to their toxic power.
How PhotoDynamic Therapy is Performed
Here is the sequence of events that constitute a complete PDT acne treatment as performed in our clinics as a multiple modality protocol.
Step #1 : Epithelial Peel
The patient’s skin undergoes a laser epithelial peel. This procedure precisely removes the dead layer of epithelium that otherwise acts as a barrier, blocking the skin’s capacity to absorb anything.
The deeper the peel, the more ALA will be absorbed creating a progressively more intense treatment. Considerable skill of assessment and skill with lasers is required by the attending physician to determine and execute the appropriate extent of the peel.
Step #2 : Application of ALA
Aminolevulinic Acid (ALA) is spread over the skin. ALA is a very mild acid that is naturally produced in our physiology.
The patient will “incubate” with ALA on their skin for 30 – 90 minutes depending on how intense the procedure needs to be. The longer the ALA remains on the skin, the more porphyrins will be created in the sebaceous cyst, leading to a more dramatic acne treatment.
Step #3 : Laser Photo Activation
The ALA is washed off the skin, and the patient undergoes the first step of photo activation. This is accomplished with the use of specific lasers that emit a frequency of energy that is target-specific for absorption by porphyrin molecules.
This step can be particularly effective on individual cysts, especially large ones that need to be individually targeted and strongly dosed with activating light.
Once again, the expertise of the attending physician is critical in determining how much energy needs to be delivered to each individual sebaceous cyst.
Step #4 : Blue-Light Photo Activation
The second phase of photo activation entails exposing the entire area being treated with a specific frequency of blue light (as seen at the beginning of this article) in order to further treat all the sebaceous glands in the entire area that is affected by cystic acne.
Singlet oxygen atoms are released within sebaceous glands throughout the area, shutting down hyperactive and overgrown cysts. The exposure time varies from 15-60 minutes.
Again, considerable expertise is needed to determine the optimal time.
Recovery from Photodynamic Therapy
Though the treatment itself is not at all difficult or painful, the following 7-10 days can be a very distressing experience. When done correctly, the patient is likely to look much worse before they look better. Treated sebaceous cysts may purge all at once, causing a dramatic and intensely ugly breakout.
A Dramatic Epithelial Peel
Furthermore, the patient should expect to experience an intense epithelial peel wherever the PDT was applied. This peel is dramatic, and if not prepared for how bad it may appear, it can be seriously scary to look at.
As a matter of fact, it is not dangerous, and though it may look like the patient’s face has been burned by some sort of horrible acid, the treatment is actually proceeding precisely as it should. The ugly PDT treated peeling skin falls off, revealing beautiful new skin underneath.
Patients typically do not experience significant pain or discomfort, and report the sensation as similar to a bad sunburn. As a rule; the more dramatic and scary the peel the better the result.
Don’t be Scared, It’s Normal
At our clinics, we are very intentional about showing every PDT patient how scary the recovery may look, so that we don’t get frantic midnight calls from the patient wondering if they should go the Emergency Room.
Bottom line, patients should be thoroughly educated with “before & after” photos of other PDT patients so that they are prepared for the peel and recovery. Additionally, though patients are fully functional during recovery, it is unlikely that anyone going through this wants to go out in public for 7-10 days… unless of course you are staring in a horror film, or your treatment happens to conveniently coincide with Halloween!
Additional Therapies to Speed Up Acne Treatment Recovery
Photodynamic Therapy protocols combined with lasers perform their magic on severe sebaceous cysts in just a few minutes while singlet oxygen atoms are released within the glands. Thus, in a few hours the treatment is complete, and the rest of the dramatic story is all about how your skin recovers. The following elements can greatly enhance the recovery process and ensure the best possible results.
As you can imagine, a dramatic purging of sebaceous glands in addition to a full epithelial peel, might present a fabulous opportunity for bacteria to settle in. Thus, as a precautionary measure, antibiotics are frequently prescribed for the course of the recovery.
Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy (HBOT)
During HBOT treatments, a patient’s body is thoroughly saturated with oxygen, down to the level of individual cells in every organ of their body. This level of oxygen saturation is not possible to achieve except through HBOT.
Accordingly, HBOT treatments are uniquely healing of many serious and debilitating conditions, and can reduce recovery time from many medical procedures including surgeries and PDT. A daily regimen of HBOT treatments will significantly accelerate the speed of recovery from PDT, and contribute to the best possible results during the regeneration of healthy new skin.
Ozone is one of the most powerful stimulants of physiological healing and regeneration in the natural world. In addition to its spectacular antiseptic properties, treatments using ozone can bring about stunning healing of disease states, as well as the regeneration of healthy functioning tissue.
Infused within natural oils, ozone is very effective as a topical lotion. Used appropriately during the recovery from PDT, ozone oils will protect the skin from infection; significantly shorten recovery time and enhance the regeneration of healthy skin.
The Final Results of These Acne Treatments
As described above, Photodynamic Therapy protocols combined with lasers are the single most effective acne treatment we have ever experienced for severe cystic acne.
Depending on the severity of the case, 2-3 treatments might be necessary. Fortunately, as sebaceous cysts are progressively shut down, each treatment is progressively easier to go through. Once successful PDT treatments have been completed, a relapse of cystic acne is very rare.
In the final analysis, it is the best and safest option for treating severe cystic acne, and the results are truly fantastic, leaving the patient with clear and healthy skin.
Lasers Combined with PDT vs. Accutane
When objectively comparing the results of Photodynamic Therapy protocols combined with lasers to other acne treatments, a 4-6 month course of the drug Accutane is the only other treatment that can achieve dramatic clearing of sebaceous cysts.
Accutane however, a very dangerous drug that has occurring in a variety of other organ systems, some of which are debilitating and life-long. Though the original drug was revoked by the FDA, it is still available through generic manufacturers, but under very restricted conditions. Many physicians refuse to prescribe it.
About the Authors
Doctors Alice Pien, MD and Asher Milgrom, Phd are established pioneers in the fields of Regenerative Medicine and Skincare. Their expertise ranges from advanced laser systems to HCT/P – Stem Cell medicine. Their medical education and advanced certifications span from medical schools of NY State University, the University of Chicago, to Johns Hopkins, Harvard and UCLA. They approach medicine with the clinical expertise of over 85,000 successful treatments over the past 20 years and significant scientific research resulting in proprietary protocols that they customize for each individual patient.
- Tang X, Li C, Ge S, Chen Z snd Lu L. Efficacy of photodynamic therapy for the treatment of inflammatory acne vulgaris: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Jan;19(1):10-21.
- Kim M, Jung H and Park H. Topical PDT in the Treatment of Benign Skin Diseases: Principles and New Applications. 2015 Oct;16(10):23259–23278.
- Hongcharu W, Taylor CR, Chang Y, Aghassi D, Suthamjariya K and Anderson RR. Topical ALA-photodynamic therapy for the treatment of acne vulgaris. 2000 Aug;115(2):183-192
- Pollock B, Turner D, Stringer MR, Bojar RA, Goulden V, Stables GI, Cunliffe WJ. Topical aminolaevulinic acid-photodynamic therapy for the treatment of acne vulgaris: a study of clinical efficacy and mechanism of action. 2004 Sep;151(3):616-22.
- Wang XL, Wang HW, Zhang LL, Guo MX and Huang Z. Topical ALA PDT for the treatment of severe acne vulgaris. 2010 Mar;7(1):33-8.
- Kim RH and Armstrong AW. Current state of acne treatment: highlighting lasers, photodynamic therapy, and chemical peels. 2011 Mar 15;17(3):2.